Cash back credit cards: will the rewards beat the cost?

Cash back pays off when you clear the bill each month and the rewards are larger than the annual fee. We do not currently list a low-fee cash back card.

A pile of US coins on a wooden table

The short version

  • Carrying a balance usually cancels out cash back. CFPB research found that people who carry debt pay 94% of total interest and fees but get less than 30% of rewards.
  • To compare cards, work out the dollars you would earn on spending you already do, then subtract the annual fee.
  • This page has no offers. The only cards we list that pay cash back are high-fee cards for rebuilding credit, and their fees can outrun the rewards.

How to work out what cash back is worth to you

Cash back is the easiest reward to value, because the CFPB notes it has an explicit dollar amount. Add up what you already put on a card in a year, then multiply. Do not count spending you would only do to earn more.

What average rewards add up to in a year
Yearly card spendingRewards at 1.6 cents per dollar
$3,000$48
$6,000$96
$12,000$192

The CFPB put average rewards at 1.6 cents per dollar spent on major issuers' cards in 2022. This is arithmetic for illustration, not an offer.

If the annual fee is larger than your figure, rewards alone will not cover it.

Bonus categories can pay less than the headline rate

A high rate on some purchases sounds better than a flat rate on all of them. It only wins if most of your spending lands in the bonus group. Issuers vary in what they count as "travel" or "groceries", and a store you think qualifies might not. Some promotions and rotating categories also make you enroll, and you earn nothing extra if you miss that step.

What can shrink or cancel your rewards

  • Redemption minimums. Some programs will not pay out until you reach a set balance.
  • Account closure. The terms of some programs say you lose unused rewards if the account closes.
  • Expiration. The CFPB found most issuers with rewards programs have an expiration policy, often tied to inactivity.
  • Sign-up bonus rules. About one in four people eligible for a promotional bonus in 2022 did not meet the terms to earn it.

Why the cash back cards we list are not on this page

Two cards we list do earn cash back, but they are built for rebuilding credit, not for earning. A Federal Reserve working paper cited by the CFPB found that near-prime and subprime cardholders typically pay more in interest and fees on a rewards card than on a card without rewards, even after counting the rewards.

Credit card, all accounts
21.19%
Up 0.25 points from the prior reading
Credit card payoff calculatorIf you carry a balance, see how long it takes to clear. Check the payoff

Questions people ask

Is cash back worth it if I carry a balance?
Rarely. Interest on a carried balance will usually be far larger than what you earn. The CFPB suggests people who carry balances look for the lowest rate, and those cards typically offer no rewards.
Is a higher percentage always better?
No. A top rate may cover only certain purchases or stop at a spending cap. Work out your own mix before you compare two cards.
Why do you not list cash back cards here?
We do not have a low-fee cash back card to show right now. We would rather explain how to judge one than put a high-fee card on a page where it would mislead you.
Can I lose cash back I have already earned?
Yes, in some cases. Closing the account, long inactivity or a program change can reduce or remove rewards, so redeem as you go.

Sources

  1. Credit Card Rewards: Issue Spotlight, May 2024 (CFPB)
  2. How to find the best credit card for you (CFPB handout)
  3. Know Before You Owe: credit cards (CFPB)