Extended auto warranty: how to tell if one is worth the cost

An extended auto warranty is a vehicle service contract, not a true warranty, and it has a price tag. It tends to make sense only if it covers repairs you would struggle to pay for, at a total cost below what those repairs are likely to run.

Advertiser disclosure
Credentree earns money from some companies on this site, usually when you click a link or apply. That can affect which offers appear and where they appear. Paid placements are labelled Ad. We do not list every product on the market. How we make money
A red car on a winding road through green hills

The short version

  • You may pay more for the contract than you ever get back in repairs, the FTC warns. Compare the full price with the repairs it would really cover.
  • If your factory warranty is still running, check its end date first. A contract that starts before that date may duplicate coverage you already have.
  • Money set aside for repairs is a real alternative. You keep it if the car never breaks down.

Offers from our advertisers

Ads. These companies pay us, which can affect which offers appear and their order. This is not every option on the market. How we choose

AdBest for: repair cost protection after the factory warranty

Endurance Auto Protection

Plan levels
Several, from powertrain (Secure) to exclusionary (Supreme); Select Premier for high mileage
Perks
24/7 roadside assistance, rental reimbursement, trip interruption; Elite Benefits need activation
Pricing
Quote based; monthly plans; deductible commonly $100 per visit, varies by plan
Guarantee
30-day money back if no claim is filed; prorated refund less a fee after that

Add up the real price before you compare

The number in the quote is only the start. The FTC says pricing can range from several hundred dollars to several thousand, and you may need to pay a deductible each time the car is serviced or repaired. The FTC also says these contracts typically exclude accident damage and normal wear and tear. If the price is rolled into a car loan, you may pay interest on it as well.

  1. Total the cost

    Add the contract price, likely deductibles, and finance charges if you would borrow to buy it.

  2. List the likely repairs

    Ask a mechanic you trust what your car may need as it ages, then remove anything the contract excludes or limits.

  3. Compare the two

    If the likely covered repairs come in below the total cost, the contract may not be a good buy for you.

Check your factory coverage dates first

Look up when your manufacturer's warranty ends, in both months and miles. The FTC says a contract should not start before that date, because you would be paying for protection you already have. Ask the seller for the exact start date and get it in writing.

Also ask how long the contract runs, whether a shorter term is available, and whether it can transfer to the next owner if you sell the car.

Questions to ask before you sign

What to ask and why it matters
AskWhy it matters
Who backs this contract?If the seller or administrator closes, you need to know who must do the work.
Who decides claims, and what can I do if one is denied?An independent administrator often makes this call, not the dealer.
Can I choose my repair shop?Some contracts limit where you can go, or require a sign-off before work starts.
How do I cancel?The contract sets the rules, so get the terms and any refund in writing.

When a repair fund may work better

If your car is reliable and you can save a little each month, a repair fund gives you flexibility. You can spend it on the repair you need, and it stays yours if nothing breaks. Our guide to building an emergency fund shows how to start small.

A contract may suit you better if one large repair bill would put you in a hard spot, and you have read the exclusions and still see real value. Just be sure the parts most likely to fail on your car are on the covered list.

Price it inside a car loanCompare your payment and total interest with and without the contract. Try the auto loan calculator

Questions people ask

How much does an extended auto warranty cost?
The FTC says prices range from several hundred to several thousand dollars. Your quote depends on the contract and the provider, and deductibles may be extra.
Should I buy from the dealer or an independent company?
Neither is automatically better. Ask both who backs the contract and what happens if a claim is denied.
Does an extended warranty cover routine maintenance?
It depends on the contract. Some cover scheduled maintenance such as oil changes, while normal wear and tear is typically left out.

Sources

  1. Auto warranties and auto service contracts (FTC)
  2. What to know about auto service contracts and extended warranty scams (FTC)
  3. Hang up on auto warranty robocalls (FTC)