Payday loan alternatives: lower-cost ways to cover a gap

There is often a cheaper way through a short cash gap than a payday loan. These options come from federal guidance, and we do not list lenders on this page.

A stone bank building with tall columns

The short version

  • If one bill is the problem, call that company first. A payment plan can cost far less than borrowing to cover it.
  • Federal credit unions can offer payday alternative loans (PALs) at up to 28% APR, with an application fee of no more than $20.
  • Free or low-cost help exists, including nonprofit credit counselors and local charities.

Start with what costs the least

  • Ask for more time. Creditors may agree to a later date or lower payments, so call before the bill is overdue.
  • Look for free help. The FTC points to family and friends, local charities and churches.
  • File your taxes early. If you are due a refund, filing sooner gets it to you sooner.
  • Ask a credit union or bank. Beyond PALs, the FTC says community banks may offer smaller loans, and some large banks offer small loans of up to $1,000.
  • Talk to a nonprofit credit counselor. The CFPB describes this as free or low-cost advice.

How credit union payday alternative loans work

Federal rules for the two types of PAL
FeaturePALs IPALs II
Amount$200 to $1,000Up to $2,000
Length1 to 6 months1 to 12 months
MembershipAt least 1 month before you borrowNo waiting period
Top APR28%28%
Application feeUp to $20Up to $20
RolloversNot allowedNot allowed
Number of loansOne at a time, at most 3 in 6 monthsOne at a time, at most 3 in 6 months

From 12 CFR 701.21 and the NCUA. A February 2026 NCUA letter says the 28% limit still applies. These rules cover federal credit unions.

A $500 PAL over six months at 28% means payments of about $90 a month and about $42 in interest. Add a $20 fee and the total cost is about $62. In the FTC example, a two-week payday loan for the same amount costs $75.

To find one, use the NCUA Credit Union Locator on MyCreditUnion.gov. You may be able to join through your employer, family, location or a group. Then ask whether it offers PALs, and which type.

How to ask for a hardship plan

  1. Call before the due date

    Explain what has changed and ask what help is available. Terms to ask about include deferment, forbearance and a payment plan.

  2. Offer a number you can keep

    Work out what your budget can carry, then propose it.

  3. Ask what the plan costs

    Find out about fees, interest and credit reporting.

  4. Get it in writing

    Keep a copy of the new terms.

Personal loan calculatorSee what payment fits your budget before you make the call. Find your number

If you already have a payday loan

Before rolling it over, add up the new fee and ask what else the lender can do. Your state regulator or attorney general can tell you what rules apply. If several bills are piling up, a credit counselor can help you decide what to pay first.

If you serve on active duty or are a covered family member, the Military Lending Act caps payday and title loans at a 36% Military Annual Percentage Rate. Personal Financial Managers and Military OneSource, 1-800-342-9647, can help you plan.

Questions people ask

Can I get a PAL if I just joined a credit union?
Possibly. PALs II has no waiting period, while PALs I requires at least one month of membership. Ask which type your credit union offers.
What is a hardship plan?
It is an arrangement with a company you owe, such as a lower payment or a later due date, for a set time.
Are paycheck advance apps a cheaper choice?
They can cost fewer dollars than a payday loan, but small fees can still mean a high APR. See our cash advance guide.

Sources

  1. Letter 26-FCU-02: loan interest rate ceiling and PALs (NCUA)
  2. Payday alternative loan rule, PALs II (NCUA)
  3. 12 CFR 701.21, federal credit union loan rules (Cornell LII copy)
  4. Is a credit union right for me? (NCUA)
  5. What to know about payday and car title loans (FTC)
  6. What is a payday loan? (CFPB)
  7. What is a personal installment loan? (CFPB)
  8. What is credit counseling? (CFPB)
  9. Military Lending Act (CFPB)