Debt relief options: which one fits where you are

If you are falling behind, a nonprofit credit counselor is usually the first call, and the advice is often free or low cost. This page compares the main routes.

Advertiser disclosure
Credentree earns money from some companies on this site, usually when you click a link or apply. That can affect which offers appear and where they appear. Paid placements are labelled Ad. We do not list every product on the market. How we make money
A note reading pay debt beside a pen and glasses

Offers from our advertisers

Ads. These companies pay us, which can affect which offers appear and their order. This is not every option on the market. How we choose

If you are falling behind, a nonprofit credit counselor is usually the first call, and the advice is often free or low cost. This page compares the main routes.

The short version

  • Falling behind, or worried you will? Call your creditors and talk with a nonprofit credit counselor before you pay anyone for relief.
  • A consolidation loan saves money only if the total cost beats what you pay now and you stop adding new debt.
  • Debt settlement can cut a balance, but it carries serious risks: credit damage, lawsuits and possible tax on forgiven amounts.

How the main options compare

Debt relief options side by side
OptionWhat happensWhat you oweMain risks
Ask your creditorYou ask for a lower payment, waived fees or a lower rate.Usually the sameThey may say no
Credit counselingA counselor builds a plan. A debt management plan means one monthly payment to the agency.Usually the same, with a lower paymentFees, and plans that can take 48 months or more
Consolidation loanA new loan pays off your old debts.The same, as a new debtLonger terms can cost more overall
Debt settlementYou save in an account while a company tries to settle for less.Possibly less, if creditors agreeCredit damage, lawsuits, fees and tax
BankruptcyA court process that can erase or restructure debts.Many debts erased or repaid on a planCan stay on your report for 10 years

A simple way to choose

  1. If you can still make your payments

    Build a budget first, then ask whether a lower rate would help. Compare a balance transfer or a consolidation loan on total cost.

  2. If you have missed or may miss a payment

    Call the card company right away, since many will work with you in a financial emergency. Then talk with a nonprofit counselor about a budget and a debt management plan.

  3. If you cannot see a way to repay

    Talk with a counselor and a bankruptcy attorney before signing with a settlement company. Some attorneys offer a free first consultation.

What each route can do to your credit

  • Consolidation loan. Expect a hard inquiry on a full application. After that, paying on time is what counts.
  • Settlement. Unpaid accounts show up as negative items, which can make other credit harder to get. Late payments can stay on your report for 7 years.
  • Bankruptcy. The FTC calls it generally a last option, because it can stay on your credit report for 10 years.

Recent negative items tend to weigh more on your score than older ones. See how credit scores work.

Warning signs that should make you walk away

  • A company wants a fee before it has settled any of your debts
  • It promises to settle all your debt for a set percentage, or says your debt will go away
  • It tells you to stop talking to your creditors
  • It tells you to stop making your minimum payments
Debt payoff calculatorSee how long your balances take to clear before you pick a route. Check your timeline

Questions people ask

Which debt relief option should I try first?
For most people who are falling behind, start with a call to the creditor and a talk with a nonprofit counselor. Both are low cost, and neither stops you from choosing another route later.
Will debt relief hurt my credit?
That depends on the route. A plan built around missed payments can do real damage, and late payments can stay on your report for years after the debt is resolved.
Is forgiven debt taxed?
In general, yes. The IRS treats canceled debt as taxable, and your creditor may send a Form 1099-C. Exclusions exist for bankruptcy and insolvency, so talk with a tax professional.
Can I handle this myself?
Yes. You can negotiate directly with a creditor or collector without paying anyone. A counselor can help you plan what to ask for.

Sources

  1. The difference between credit counseling, debt settlement, debt consolidation and credit repair (CFPB)
  2. How to get out of debt (FTC)
  3. What is a debt relief program and how do I know if I should use one? (CFPB)
  4. Advertisements for companies that consolidate credit card debt: are these legitimate? (CFPB)
  5. What should I do if I cannot pay my credit card bills? (CFPB)
  6. How to rebuild your credit (CFPB)
  7. Topic no. 431, canceled debt: is it taxable or not? (IRS)