Home improvement financing: match the way you pay to the project

Get the price of the job first, then choose how to pay. A small repair and a full roof call for different tools, and the lowest rate can come with the highest risk.

A kitchen in the middle of a renovation

The short version

  • Get several written estimates before you look at financing. The FTC says not to pick the lowest bid automatically, and to ask about big price differences.
  • For smaller jobs you can repay quickly, savings or a card may be enough. For larger jobs, compare a fixed-payment loan with borrowing against your home.
  • Think twice if a contractor offers to arrange your loan. The FTC warns this can lead to a high-cost home equity loan and unfinished work.

How to match financing to the size of the job

We do not quote typical project costs here, because prices depend on your home, your area and the materials. Your written estimates give you the number that counts. Once you have them, use this as a rough guide.

Ways to pay, by project size
Project sizeOften a fitWatch for
Small, and you can repay within monthsSavings, or a credit card you can clear quicklyInterest if a balance lingers, and deferred-interest promotions
Medium, and you want a set payoff dateA fixed-rate personal or home improvement loanFees, and whether the loan is secured by your home
Large, and you have home equityA home equity loan or line of creditYour home is collateral, and a line usually has a variable rate
Urgent, such as a failed roofAsk your insurer first, then consider the options abovePressure to sign quickly

A guide only. Your costs, credit and equity decide what works for you.

Read more about home improvement loans and paying with a credit card. These national averages show how far apart personal loan and card rates can sit. Your own quote will differ.

24-month personal loan
11.90%
Up 0.04 points from the prior reading
Credit card, all accounts
21.19%
Up 0.25 points from the prior reading
Test a monthly paymentEnter your estimate, a quoted rate and a term to see what the job would cost per month. Open the personal loan calculator

Hire the contractor before you settle the money

  1. Check license and insurance

    Confirm the license with your state or county and ask for proof of insurance.

  2. Collect written estimates

    Ask about large price differences instead of defaulting to the lowest bid.

  3. Get a full contract

    It should show the name, address, phone, license number, and estimated start and finish dates. Fill in every blank.

  4. Stage your payments

    Do not pay the full amount up front, since some states limit down payments. Hold the final payment until the work is done and you are satisfied.

Red flags to take seriously

  • A knock on the door from someone "in the area," or with leftover materials from another job.
  • Pressure to decide on the spot.
  • A demand for full payment up front, or cash only.
  • A request that you get the building permits yourself.
  • A suggestion that you borrow from a lender they know.

Questions people ask

What is the cheapest way to pay for home improvements?
Savings cost no interest. After that, it depends on your credit and equity. Loans backed by your home usually have lower rates than unsecured loans, but you could lose your home if you cannot pay.
Should I use a home equity line for a renovation?
It can suit a job paid in stages. The CFPB says to consider one if you are confident you can keep up with the payments, since you could lose your home if you cannot, and to shop around on features and fees.
How much should I pay a contractor up front?
There is no single rule. The FTC says not to pay the full amount up front, and some states limit down payments, so check with your state or local consumer agency.

Sources

  1. How to avoid a home improvement scam (FTC)
  2. What you should know about home equity lines of credit (CFPB)
  3. Differentiating between secured and unsecured loans (CFPB)