Cheap car insurance: lower the price without losing the cover you need

No company is cheapest for every driver. You get a lower price by comparing the same cover across insurers, asking about discounts, and trimming only what you could afford to lose.

Advertiser disclosure
Credentree earns money from some companies on this site, usually when you click a link or apply. That can affect which offers appear and where they appear. Paid placements are labelled Ad. We do not list every product on the market. How we make money
A red car on a winding road through green hills

The short version

  • There is no single cheapest insurer. Your record, area, car and mileage all feed into your price, so get several quotes.
  • Ask about discounts by name: multiple vehicles, driver education, good student and safety devices.
  • Drop optional cover only when you could pay for the loss yourself, and never go below what your state or lender requires.

Offers from our advertisers

Ads. These companies pay us, which can affect which offers appear and their order. This is not every option on the market. How we choose

AdBest for: Building cover around a budget

Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance

Coverage
Auto, home, renters, condo, motorcycle and umbrella
Discounts
Multi-policy and RightTrack safe driving, up to 30% after a 90-day review; not in all states
Optional extras
Accident forgiveness, New Car Replacement, Better Car Replacement; extra cost
Financial strength
AM Best A (Excellent), as of Sept. 2025
Availability
Most states and D.C.; cover and discounts vary by state
AdBest for: Requesting auto quotes from several insurers at once

Cheap Insure Rates

What you get
One form to request auto quotes from several insurers
Cost
Free to request; no obligation to buy
What sets your rate
Driving record, location, age, vehicle, mileage, limits and deductibles; varies by state
How to compare
Get at least three quotes with identical limits and deductibles
AdBest for: Reading quotes side by side

Policy Plug

What it is
Online form that requests auto quotes from your ZIP, vehicle and driver details
Cost
Free to request; no obligation to buy
Credit impact
A quote check is a soft inquiry and does not affect your credit scores
Expect follow-up
Partner insurers or agents may call, text or email after you submit

A low quote only counts if the cover matches

Two quotes can differ because one has lower limits, a higher deductible or no collision. Line these up before you choose on price.

What to line up on each quote
CheckWhy it matters
Liability limitsLower limits can cost less, but they leave you paying more yourself after a serious crash
DeductiblesThis is your share of a claim before the insurer pays, so a higher one shifts cost to you
Collision and comprehensiveA quote without them may look cheap because it will not pay to fix or replace your car
Drivers and cars listedA missing driver or car makes the quote look lower than what you would really pay
Optional extrasRental and towing add to the price, so include or leave them out on every quote

Discounts worth asking about

The NAIC suggests looking for these. Not all states offer all of them, so ask each company what applies where you live.

  • Multiple vehicles on one policy
  • A driver education course
  • Good student status
  • Safety devices on the car

Ask for the price with and without each discount, and ask whether a discount ends after the first policy term.

What you can trim, and what to keep

The NAIC points out that with an older car, repair costs can quickly exceed what the car is worth. If you own that car outright and could replace it yourself, price your policy with and without collision and comprehensive.

May be worth trimming

  • Collision or comprehensive on an older car you own outright
  • Rental reimbursement, if you have another way to get around
  • Towing and labor, if you already have roadside help elsewhere

Think twice before trimming

  • Anything your state requires
  • Collision, if your loan or lease requires it
  • Liability limits, since they stand between a serious crash and your savings
  • Uninsured motorist cover, which protects you directly

What lowers your price over time

Some factors move slowly but are in your hands. Your driving record, your annual mileage and the make and model you buy next all feed into the quote. If you are choosing a car, get an insurance quote before you sign.

Shopping for a car?Add the insurance quote to the loan payment before you decide what you can afford. Try the auto loan calculator

Questions people ask

What is the cheapest car insurance?
There is no single answer. Price depends on your driving record, where you live, your car and other factors, so the cheapest company for you may not be the cheapest for your neighbor.
Is the state minimum enough?
It keeps you legal, but it may not be enough. Minimum liability does not pay to fix your own car, and a serious crash can cost more than low limits pay.
How often should I compare quotes?
A good time is before each renewal, and after a move, a new car or a change in who drives, since those details feed into your price.
Do discounts apply in every state?
No. The NAIC notes that not all states offer all discounts, so check with the company or agent.

Sources

  1. Auto insurance consumer guide (NAIC)
  2. Insurance Departments directory (NAIC)