Ad
Advertiser disclosure
Credentree earns money from some companies on this site, usually when you click a link or apply. That can affect which offers appear and where they appear. Paid placements are labelled Ad. We do not list every product on the market. How we make money

Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance: adjusting cover and deductibles to fit a budget

One insurer's car policy, where you set the coverages and deductibles yourself in the quote. Independent reviews often put its premiums above average, so compare it with other insurers before you buy.

The short version

  • Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance lets you adjust coverages and deductibles in its online quote. The price falls as the cover does, so know where to stop.
  • Coverage, discounts and add-ons vary by state, and the RightTrack discount is only set at renewal after a 90-day review. Rely on the quote and policy wording you get.
  • The company behind the offer makes every decision and sets the terms, not Credentree.

At a glance

This offer leads to a car insurance quote from one company. Liberty Mutual sells auto, home, renters, condo, motorcycle and umbrella policies in most states and D.C. Its "only pay for what you need" line means you set the coverages and deductibles yourself in the online quote, which is the budget angle it is listed for.

That control is useful, but a budget should not be the only test. Lower limits and fewer coverages cut the price by moving risk back to you, and independent reviews often describe its premiums as above average. Decide which losses you could pay yourself, then ask at least one other insurer to quote the same cover.

Pros and cons

What works

  • A direct quote from one named insurer, rated A (Excellent) for financial strength by a major rating agency as of September 2025
  • You adjust limits, deductibles and add-ons in the quote and watch the price move
  • Discounts include multi-policy and RightTrack, up to 30% off for safe driving
  • Optional add-ons: accident forgiveness, New Car Replacement and Better Car Replacement

What to weigh

  • You see one company's price, so it tells you nothing about others
  • Cutting cover to hit a number can leave a gap you only find after a claim
  • RightTrack is set at renewal after a 90-day driving review, is not in every state, and some drivers end up paying more
  • The add-ons cost extra, and accident forgiveness is not sold in every state and usually needs about five violation-free years

Who it suits

A reasonable fit if

  • You have a monthly figure in mind and want to see what it buys
  • You are already collecting quotes from a few insurers
  • You also need home, renters, condo or motorcycle cover and want one company for all of it

Look elsewhere if

  • You want to see several insurers from a single form
  • A lender requires cover you are hoping to cut
  • You are looking for one quote and plan to stop there
See Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance cover options (opens the advertiser's site in a new tab)

Opens the advertiser's site.

How it works

  1. Start with what is required

    Check what your state and any lender require before you set a budget.

  2. Get a quote at the cover you want

    Where credit is used in pricing, the quote is a soft inquiry, which does not affect your credit score. Then change one deductible or add-on at a time and watch the price.

  3. Compare before you pay

    Put the final quote next to another insurer at the same limits and deductibles. The insurer sets the final cover and price.

Questions people ask

How do I keep the price down without losing cover I need?
Start with discounts: a second Liberty Mutual policy earns a multi-policy discount, and RightTrack can take up to 30% off at renewal. Only then cut optional cover you could do without. Our guide to cheaper car insurance sets out the order.
Is the RightTrack discount a sure thing?
No. It is set at renewal after a 90-day review of your driving, it is not offered in every state, and some drivers end up paying more. Skip it if you would rather not share your driving data.
Can I drop collision to fit my budget?
Not if your loan or lease requires it. If you own the car outright, price the policy both ways and consider what the car is worth.
Is this offer available in my state?
Liberty Mutual sells in most states and D.C., but coverages, discounts and add-ons change from state to state. The quote form will tell you, and your state insurance department can confirm a license.

Know what your budget buys?

Get the Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance quote at the cover you want, then have another insurer price the same limits before you decide.

Go to Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance (opens the advertiser's site in a new tab)

Sources

  1. Auto insurance consumer guide (NAIC)
  2. Insurance Departments directory (NAIC)