Short-term installment loans: how the payments add up

An installment loan lets you repay over several payments instead of all at once. That can make each payment easier to fit, but the total depends on the APR and how long you pay.

A monthly planner with two pens

The short version

  • Several smaller payments can be easier to manage than one lump sum, which is the main advantage over a typical payday loan.
  • The APR decides the outcome. On $1,000 over 12 months, interest is about $158 at 28% and about $3,047 at 391%.
  • Compare an offer with a credit union payday alternative loan, which can run up to 12 months at no more than 28%.

How a short-term installment loan works

You receive the money at the start and repay it in fixed amounts on a set schedule. The CFPB notes that some payday loans are also set up to be repaid in installments, so the name alone tells you little about the price.

Online lenders may ask to take payments from your bank account automatically. The CFPB warns that this access can be hard to cancel, so read that part of the agreement first.

Same $1,000, very different totals

$1,000 repaid over 12 months at three APRs
APRWhere the rate comes fromMonthly paymentTotal interest
28%Limit on federal credit union payday alternative loans$96.51$158
36%Military Lending Act cap$100.46$206
391%FTC example for a two-week payday loan$337.26$3,047

Example math with no fees, not a quote. We apply 391% to a 12-month term only to show what a high APR does over time. Real installment APRs vary by lender and state.

At 391%, about $326 of the first $337 payment goes to interest, so the balance barely moves at first. At 28%, cutting the term from 12 months to six lowers the interest from $158 to about $83.

Personal loan calculatorTest a quote at different lengths and see the total. Compare lengths

Installment loan or payday loan?

How the two usually differ
FeatureTypical payday loanShort-term installment loan
RepaymentOne payment, usually in two to four weeksSeveral payments over months
If money runs shortA rollover adds a fee and leaves the full amount owingLate fees, collections and credit damage, so call the lender early
Best way to compareDollar fee and APRAPR and total repaid

Neither type is automatically cheaper. A shorter loan costs fewer dollars at the same APR, while a lower APR can make a longer loan cost less overall.

What to check before you sign

  • The APR and total of payments in the loan disclosure.
  • Origination or documentation fees, plus credit insurance added to the loan, which the CFPB says is generally optional.
  • Whether you can pay early without a penalty.
  • Whether the lender is licensed in your state.

The Military Lending Act covers installment loans other than auto loans. Covered borrowers cannot be charged more than a 36% Military Annual Percentage Rate or a prepayment penalty.

If the payment would strain your budget, this may be a poor fit. A credit union loan, or more time from the company you owe, may cost less.

Questions people ask

Is a short-term installment loan the same as a personal loan?
They work in much the same way, with set payments over a set time. Lenders use these names loosely, so judge each loan by its APR and total.
Can paying early save money?
Often, because interest usually builds on the balance you still owe. Check the agreement for a prepayment penalty first.
What if I cannot make a payment?
Contact the lender before the due date. The CFPB says deferment, forbearance or a payment plan may be possible.

Sources

  1. What is a personal installment loan? (CFPB)
  2. Do personal installment loans have fees? (CFPB)
  3. What is a payday loan? (CFPB)
  4. What to know about payday and car title loans (FTC)
  5. Getting a payday loan online, including lead generators (CFPB)
  6. 12 CFR 701.21, federal credit union loan rules (Cornell LII copy)
  7. Letter 26-FCU-02: loan interest rate ceiling and PALs (NCUA)
  8. Military Lending Act (CFPB)