Cash advance loans: three products with one name

People say "cash advance" for a credit card withdrawal, a paycheck advance and a payday loan. Their costs differ, so start by working out which one you are looking at.

A hand pressing the keypad of a cash machine

The short version

  • A credit card cash advance starts charging interest the day you take it, usually at a higher rate than purchases, and fees can apply on top.
  • A paycheck advance can look cheap in dollars. The CFPB worked out that $3.18 in fees on a $106 advance for 10 days equals about 109.5% APR.
  • A payday loan sold as a cash advance typically costs $15 per $100 for two weeks, or about 391% APR.

How the three kinds compare

Three products often called a cash advance
TypeHow it worksWhat it costsCheck first
Credit card advanceYou withdraw cash against your cardA flat or percentage fee, possible ATM fees, and a usually higher rate with no grace periodYour cash advance limit and rate
Paycheck advanceYou get part of your pay early, through an employer program or an appFees for faster delivery, and with some apps a monthly fee or a request for tipsWhether a slower option costs less
Payday loanA lender gives you cash against a post-dated check or bank debitIn many states, capped at $10 to $30 per $100The due date and what happens if you cannot pay

What a credit card cash advance costs

The CFPB treats this as a short-term loan that can be expensive. Interest starts as soon as you take the money, and some cards set a separate, lower limit for advances.

What paycheck advances cost

With these products you mostly pay for speed. In a 2024 CFPB study of employer-linked programs, fees for faster delivery made up 96.6% of what workers paid. The average advance was about $106, repaid in about 10 days, and transactions with a fee averaged $3.18.

Apps that work directly with you can add monthly fees or ask for tips. The CFPB gave one example: about $8 in fees and tips on a $144 advance for seven days, or about 290% APR. The dollars can still be lower than a payday fee, so compare both the APR and the dollar cost.

When a cash advance is really a payday loan

If a store or website offers cash until payday and asks for a post-dated check or access to your bank account, you are probably looking at a payday loan.

Covered servicemembers and their families have a 36% cap under the Military Lending Act, which applies to payday loans, deposit advances and credit cards.

What to try first

  • Ask for more time. The company you owe may agree to a later date or a plan.
  • Ask a credit union. Payday alternative loans are capped at 28% APR, with an application fee of up to $20.
  • Get free help. A nonprofit credit counselor can work through your budget with you.
  • Compare an installment loan. If you need more than an advance covers, or longer to repay, an installment loan may fit.
APR calculatorTurn any advance fee into an APR. Convert a fee

Questions people ask

Is a cash advance a loan?
A card advance and a payday loan are. Paycheck advance products are built in different ways, so read the terms to see what you owe and when.
Where do I find the rate on my card?
Your latest statement lists the cash advance rate. Your card terms, or the number on the back of the card, can confirm the fee and limit.
Which type is cheapest?
It depends on the amount and how long you need it. Compare the total dollars for the same amount over the same time, and include a credit union loan.

Sources

  1. Withdrawing money from a credit card at an ATM (CFPB)
  2. Data spotlight: the paycheck advance market (CFPB, July 2024)
  3. What is a payday loan? (CFPB)
  4. What to know about payday and car title loans (FTC)
  5. Military Lending Act (CFPB)
  6. Letter 26-FCU-02: loan interest rate ceiling and PALs (NCUA)
  7. 12 CFR 701.21, federal credit union loan rules (Cornell LII copy)
  8. What is credit counseling? (CFPB)