Debt consolidation loans: when one payment really saves money

A consolidation loan replaces several debts with one new loan. It saves money only when the total you repay comes out lower, which is a different test from a smaller payment.

A thick stack of bills and papers

The short version

  • Compare total cost, not the payment. A lower monthly bill can mean a longer term, and you could pay much more overall.
  • A loan moves your debt without erasing it. If spending still runs ahead of income, the balances tend to come back.
  • Some consolidation ads are settlement in disguise. If you are told to stop paying your debts and fund a special account, that is not a loan.

How to tell if the loan beats what you pay now

  1. List what you owe today

    Write down each balance, rate and monthly payment. Then estimate what you would pay in total if you kept going.

  2. Get the full loan terms

    You need the APR, the term and any upfront charges. The FTC notes some loans charge points, where one point is 1% of the amount you borrow.

  3. Compare the two totals

    Multiply the new payment by the number of months and add any upfront charges. If that beats your current path, the loan is doing its job.

  4. Check for teaser rates

    A low starting rate may rise after a set period. Run your numbers at the later rate too.

24-month personal loan
11.90%
Up 0.04 points from the prior reading
Credit card, all accounts
21.19%
Up 0.25 points from the prior reading

These Federal Reserve averages give you a rough sense of the gap between card rates and personal loan rates. Your own offer depends on your credit, and damaged credit may keep you from the lower rates.

Debt payoff calculatorEstimate your current path, then compare it with the loan you are offered. Estimate my current path

How a loan compares with other ways to consolidate

Ways to combine debts
RouteWhat backs itMain thing to watch
Unsecured consolidation loanNothing but your promise to repayLong terms and fees that raise the total
Balance transfer cardNothingThe transfer fee, and a rate that rises when the offer ends
Home equity loanYour homeYou could lose your home to foreclosure, and closing costs can run to hundreds or thousands of dollars

Ads that say consolidation but mean settlement

According to the CFPB, many firms that advertise debt consolidation may in fact be settlement companies. The two work in opposite ways. A loan pays your creditors off. Settlement usually has you stop paying them and put money in a special account instead.

When a consolidation loan is the wrong move

  • You spend more than you earn each month, so new balances would build on top of the loan
  • The payment only fits your budget on a term much longer than your current path
  • You are already missing payments, in which case a nonprofit credit counselor is a better first call

Questions people ask

Will a consolidation loan hurt my credit?
A full loan application usually brings a hard inquiry. Checking rates with a soft inquiry does not affect your credit score, where a lender offers that. See soft and hard checks.
How soon could I get the money?
It depends on the lender. Funding can take days, if approved. Keep paying your current bills until the debts are paid off.
What credit score do I need?
Lenders set their own rules. A lower score can keep you from the low rates that make consolidating worth doing.
What if a company tells me to stop paying my cards?
Treat that as debt settlement, whatever the ad called it. Ask a nonprofit counselor for a second view before you sign.

Sources

  1. What do I need to know about consolidating my credit card debt? (CFPB)
  2. Advertisements for companies that consolidate credit card debt: are these legitimate? (CFPB)
  3. How to get out of debt (FTC)
  4. The difference between credit counseling, debt settlement, debt consolidation and credit repair (CFPB)
  5. NCUA Board extends loan interest rate ceiling (NCUA)