Secured vs unsecured debt: what you could lose if you cannot pay

Secured debt is backed by something you own, such as a car or a home, and the lender can take it if you do not repay. Unsecured debt has no collateral, but the lender can still send it to collections or sue you.

A model house and a set of keys on a wooden table

The short version

  • Secured loans usually cost less and allow larger amounts, because the lender has collateral. The trade-off is that you can lose the property.
  • Unsecured debt does not let a lender automatically take your property, but missed payments can hurt your credit and you might be sued.
  • If money is tight, knowing which of your debts are secured tells you what is at stake on each one.

Secured and unsecured debt side by side

How the two kinds of debt usually differ
QuestionSecuredUnsecured
What backs itCollateral, such as a home, car or bank depositNothing, it rests on your income and credit record
Interest rateUsually lowerMay be higher, since the lender takes more risk
Borrowing limitUsually higherUsually lower
Time to repayUsually longerOften shorter
Getting approvedMay be easier if you are new to credit or rebuildingLenders may use stricter criteria
Common examplesMortgage, car loan, home equity lineMost credit cards, personal loans, student loans

Based on CFPB educational material. Some products can fall into either group, so check your own agreement.

What can happen if you stop paying

With a secured loan, the lender can take the collateral to get its money back, and your property may be sold to pay off the loan. That is not always the end of it. The lender can also report late payments, use debt collection and might sue you.

With an unsecured loan, the lender cannot automatically take your property. It can still report missed payments to the credit bureaus, start debt collection and might take you to court.

What national rate averages show

These averages show the usual pattern. A new car loan is secured by the car, while personal loans and credit cards usually are not. Rates for any one person can sit far from these figures.

60-month new car loan
7.54%
Up 0.40 points from the prior reading
24-month personal loan
11.90%
Up 0.04 points from the prior reading
Credit card, all accounts
21.19%
Up 0.25 points from the prior reading

How to think about which one fits

  • Secured may fit if you are buying the thing that backs the loan, like a home or car, or if you need a starting point with thin credit.
  • Unsecured may fit if the need is short-term and you would rather not put property on the line.
  • Be careful either way with the total cost. A lower rate over a longer term can still cost more overall.

List your debts by what backs them

  1. Write down each debt

    Include the balance, the rate and the monthly payment.

  2. Mark what backs it

    Check your loan papers for collateral or a lien.

  3. Ask for help early

    Call the lender before you miss a payment. A nonprofit credit counselor can help you review the whole picture.

Map out your debt payoffEnter your balances and rates to see how long payoff could take. Open the debt payoff calculator

Questions people ask

Is a credit card secured or unsecured?
Most credit cards are unsecured. A secured credit card is a different product, designed to help you establish or build credit.
Can unsecured debt lead to losing my home?
A lender cannot automatically take your property on unsecured debt, but it might sue you. If that happens, get legal advice, since what follows depends on the court and your state.
Is secured debt always cheaper?
No. Secured loans usually have lower rates, but fees, terms and your credit all matter. Compare the APR and the total you would repay.

Sources

  1. Differentiating between secured and unsecured loans (CFPB)
  2. What you should know about home equity lines of credit (CFPB)