Debt settlement: how it works and what can go wrong

Debt settlement companies try to get creditors to accept less than you owe, while you save money in an account and usually stop paying those bills. It can cut a balance, and it can also leave you deeper in debt.

Advertiser disclosure
Credentree earns money from some companies on this site, usually when you click a link or apply. That can affect which offers appear and where they appear. Paid placements are labelled Ad. We do not list every product on the market. How we make money
A note reading pay debt beside a pen and glasses

The short version

  • The CFPB calls dealing with these companies risky. Missed payments can bring late fees, collection calls, lawsuits and lasting credit damage.
  • Under the FTC rule for debt relief sold by phone, a company cannot collect its fee until it has settled a debt, you have agreed to the deal and you have made a payment under it.
  • Try the cheaper routes first. Your creditor or a nonprofit credit counselor may get you further at lower risk, and forgiven debt may be taxed.

Offers from our advertisers

Ads. These companies pay us, which can affect which offers appear and their order. This is not every option on the market. How we choose

AdBest for: settling larger unsecured balances

National Debt Relief

Program type
Debt settlement
Minimum debt
$7,500 in unsecured debt
Fees
15%-25% of enrolled debt, only after a settlement you approve
Timeline
Typically 24-48 months

How a settlement program works

  1. You enroll and usually stop paying

    These programs often encourage you to stop monthly payments to your creditors.

  2. You save in a dedicated account

    You pay into the account each month. The money stays yours, and you can withdraw it without penalty.

  3. The company negotiates

    Once you have saved enough, it tries to settle each debt for a lump sum below the full balance.

  4. You approve and pay

    If you accept a settlement and pay under it, the company can collect its fee for that debt.

What can go wrong along the way

  • The balance can grow. Interest and penalty fees keep adding up while you are not paying.
  • Your credit takes a hit. Unpaid accounts show as negative items, which makes other credit harder to get.
  • You can be sued. Creditors may keep collecting, hire collectors or file a lawsuit.
  • Not every debt settles. Many lenders will not negotiate with these companies, and some debts may stay unresolved.
  • You may not finish. If you cannot keep saving, you could end up owing more in late fees and interest.

What the FTC rule says about fees and disclosures

The Telemarketing Sales Rule covers for-profit sellers of debt relief by phone, including calls you make in response to an ad. Businesses that meet you face to face before signing you up are generally outside it. Under the rule:

  • No fee comes before a settlement, and fees cannot be front-loaded.
  • Before you sign up, the company must disclose its fees, how long results will take, how much you must save before it makes an offer, and what missed payments can do.

Tax on the debt you no longer owe

The IRS says canceled debt is generally taxable, and you report it for the year it was canceled. A creditor may send you Form 1099-C showing the amount. You may be able to exclude it if the debt was canceled in bankruptcy or to the extent you were insolvent, which you report on Form 982. Talk with a tax professional before you count your savings.

When settlement may fit, and what to try first

May be worth discussing if

  • You are already far behind and a repayment plan will not work
  • You can set aside money each month for lump-sum offers
  • You have weighed bankruptcy with an attorney

Try something else first if

  • You are current on your payments
  • A nonprofit counselor can build a plan you can afford

Questions people ask

How much does debt settlement cost?
Fees vary by company. They can be a share of the debt resolved or a share of the amount saved. Get the total in writing, then add it to what you pay creditors and any tax.
Could I be sued during a settlement program?
Yes. Working with a settlement company does not stop creditors from collecting or filing a lawsuit.
Is settlement the same as consolidation?
No. A consolidation loan pays your debts in full with new borrowing. Settlement aims to pay less than you owe, and usually means missing payments along the way.

Sources

  1. How to get out of debt (FTC)
  2. Debt relief services and the Telemarketing Sales Rule: a guide for business (FTC)
  3. What is a debt relief program and how do I know if I should use one? (CFPB)
  4. The difference between credit counseling, debt settlement, debt consolidation and credit repair (CFPB)
  5. Advertisements for companies that consolidate credit card debt: are these legitimate? (CFPB)
  6. Topic no. 431, canceled debt: is it taxable or not? (IRS)