Short-term loans: what they cost and what costs less

If you need money before your next paycheck, a payday loan is not your only choice. Here is what each option costs in plain dollars.

A leather wallet holding a stack of dollar bills

The short version

  • A typical two-week payday loan costs $15 per $100. On $500, that is a $75 fee and an APR of about 391%.
  • A federal credit union payday alternative loan is capped at 28% APR, plus an application fee of up to $20. On $500 over six months, that comes to about $62.
  • If one bill is the problem, ask that company for more time first. Then see our lower-cost options.

What short-term credit costs in dollars

Examples based on federal agency figures, side by side
TypeExampleWhat it costsAPR
Payday loan$500 for two weeks at $15 per $100$75, or $150 if rolled over onceAbout 391%
Car title loan$1,000 for 30 days at a 25% monthly fee$250About 300%
Payday alternative loan$500 over six months at the 28% capAbout $62, including a $20 application feeUp to 28%, plus the fee
Credit card cash advanceDepends on your cardA fee, plus interest from day oneSee your statement

Payday and title examples are from the FTC. The credit union figure is our math using NCUA limits. State rules and lender terms can change these numbers.

A fee can look small because the loan is short. APR puts loans of different lengths on the same scale. For comparison, the CFPB says credit card APRs range from about 12% to about 30%.

How the main types differ

  • Payday loans are generally $500 or less and come due in two to four weeks, often through a post-dated check or bank debit.
  • Car title loans use your vehicle as security and typically last 15 or 30 days.
  • Installment loans spread repayment over several payments, and the APR decides whether that saves you money.
  • Cash advances can mean a card withdrawal, a paycheck advance or a payday loan.
  • Payday alternative loans come from federal credit unions, at up to $2,000 with no rollovers.

Why your state and military status change the rules

Many states cap payday loan fees and sizes, and some do not allow payday lending at all. Your state regulator or attorney general can tell you what applies. The CFPB also says you may have more protection with a lender licensed in your state.

If you serve on active duty, or you are a covered spouse or dependent, the Military Lending Act caps payday, title and most installment loans at a 36% Military Annual Percentage Rate, which counts many fees as well as interest. Personal Financial Managers and Military OneSource (1-800-342-9647) offer help.

How to choose when money is tight

  1. Pin down the gap

    Work out how much you need and when you can pay it back in full.

  2. Ask the company you owe

    More time on a bill may cost less than a loan to cover it.

  3. Try lower-cost credit

    Ask a credit union about payday alternative loans. The FTC says community banks may offer smaller loans, and some large banks offer small loans of up to $1,000.

  4. If you still need a loan, compare in dollars

    Look at total repaid, due dates and whether the payments fit. Money can arrive as soon as the next business day, if approved, but speed does not lower the price.

APR calculatorTurn a fee and a due date into an APR you can compare. Find the APR

Questions people ask

What does a short-term loan really cost?
Add up every dollar you repay above what you borrowed. In the FTC example, $500 for two weeks costs $75.
What happens if I roll over a payday loan?
Where state law allows it, you pay the fee and the due date moves. You still owe the full amount, plus a new fee next time.
Do states limit payday loans?
Many do, by capping fees and loan sizes. Some states do not allow them. Check with your state regulator or attorney general.
Is an installment loan cheaper than a payday loan?
Not automatically. Smaller payments can be easier to manage, but a high APR over many months can cost more in total. Compare the dollars.

Sources

  1. What is a payday loan? (CFPB)
  2. What to know about payday and car title loans (FTC)
  3. Letter 26-FCU-02: loan interest rate ceiling and PALs (NCUA)
  4. 12 CFR 701.21, federal credit union loan rules (Cornell LII copy)
  5. Military Lending Act (CFPB)
  6. Getting a payday loan online, including lead generators (CFPB)
  7. Withdrawing money from a credit card at an ATM (CFPB)