Home improvement loans: what to compare before you borrow

A home improvement loan gives you a lump sum to pay back on a schedule. The first question to ask is whether your home secures it, because that changes the rate you may get and what you risk.

The wooden frame of a house seen from above

The short version

  • Ask if the loan is secured by your home. Secured loans usually have lower rates, but the lender can take the property if you cannot repay.
  • Compare the APR, the fees and the total you would repay across several lenders, using the same amount and term for each.
  • Shop for your own loan. The FTC warns against agreeing to contractor-arranged financing until you have compared terms and understand them.

Secured by your home, or not

Two kinds of home improvement loan
FeatureUnsecured loanLoan secured by your home
CollateralNone, it is based on your income and credit recordYour home
Interest rateMay be higher, because the lender takes more riskUsually lower
How much you can borrowUsually lessUsually more
Time to repayOften shorterUsually longer
If you cannot payDebt collection, credit damage, and you might be suedAll of those, and you could lose your home

Based on CFPB educational material. Individual loans differ.

The CFPB's teaching material sorts home improvement loans with secured loans and personal loans with unsecured ones, but the label on an offer does not settle it. Ask the lender directly, and read the documents for any mention of a lien or mortgage on your property. A smaller job may not need your home as collateral, while a larger one may justify it if you can carry the risk. See secured and unsecured debt.

What to compare across offers

  • APR: it reflects the rate plus certain charges, so it gives a fuller picture than the rate alone.
  • Fees: ask if origination or application fees come out of the loan amount or get added to it.
  • Term and payment: a longer term lowers the payment and usually raises the total interest.
  • Early payoff: ask if you can pay the loan off early without a penalty.
  • Total repaid: add up all the payments. That tells you what the project really costs when you borrow for it.

This national average for 24-month personal loans can help you judge a quote. It is not an offer.

24-month personal loan
11.90%
Up 0.04 points from the prior reading
Try a payment and termSee how a shorter or longer term changes your payment and total interest. Use the personal loan calculator

Checking rates without hurting your credit

Many lenders let you check a rate with a soft inquiry, which does not affect your credit score. Confirm this before you start, because a full application usually involves a hard inquiry. Read more about soft and hard credit checks.

Be careful with loans a contractor arranges

Some contractors offer to set up financing through a lender they know. The FTC describes a scheme where homeowners end up with a home equity loan at a high rate, with points and fees, sometimes through blank or rushed paperwork, and the work may go unfinished. Shop around and understand the terms before you agree to anything.

Questions people ask

Is a home improvement loan better than a credit card?
For a larger project you will repay over years, a fixed loan may give you a lower rate and a set end date. For a small job you can clear soon, a card may be simpler.
Does a home improvement loan use my house as collateral?
Some do and some do not. Ask the lender and check the documents, since a loan secured by your home can lead to foreclosure if you fail to repay.
What credit score do I need?
Lenders set their own standards, so there is no single number. Your score affects the cost of the loan, and it helps to check your credit reports for errors first.

Sources

  1. Differentiating between secured and unsecured loans (CFPB)
  2. How to avoid a home improvement scam (FTC)
  3. What is the difference between a mortgage interest rate and an APR? (CFPB)