How to compare debt relief companies

The best debt relief is the route that fits your situation at the lowest risk, and for many people that starts with a nonprofit counselor, not a company on a list.

Advertiser disclosure
Credentree earns money from some companies on this site, usually when you click a link or apply. That can affect which offers appear and where they appear. Paid placements are labelled Ad. We do not list every product on the market. How we make money
A magnifying glass on a blue surface

The short version

  • No company is best for everyone. Compare what each one would really do for you, and get it in writing.
  • Check what an ad is really selling: a loan you repay in full, or settlement, where you usually stop paying while a company asks creditors to accept less.
  • Try the low-cost routes first. Your creditor and a nonprofit credit counselor cost little or nothing to ask.

Offers from our advertisers

Ads. These companies pay us, which can affect which offers appear and their order. This is not every option on the market. How we choose

AdBest for: settling larger unsecured balances

National Debt Relief

Program type
Debt settlement
Minimum debt
$7,500 in unsecured debt
Fees
15%-25% of enrolled debt, only after a settlement you approve
Timeline
Typically 24-48 months

Start by naming what you are being sold

How to tell the products apart
ProductSigns you are looking at itQuestion to ask
Consolidation loanYou see an APR, a term and a fixed monthly payment. You repay everything you borrow.What will I pay in total, with fees?
Debt settlementYou pay into an account instead of your creditors, and fees come after a settlement.What happens to my accounts while I save?
Credit counselingYou get a budget review, and maybe a plan with one payment to an agency.What are the setup and monthly fees?

Five checks that separate one company from another

  1. Total cost in writing. Before you sign up, a company selling debt relief by phone must disclose its fees, conditions and refund policy.
  2. Time to results. It must also say how long results will take and how much you must save before it makes a settlement offer.
  3. How savings figures are worked out. Under the FTC rule, a savings claim must start from your debt at enrollment, count the fees and include people who dropped out or whose debts did not settle.
  4. Who controls your money. In a dedicated account the money is yours. You can leave at any time and get it back within seven business days, minus fees already earned.
  5. Complaints. Check with your state attorney general and local consumer protection agency. A clean record is a good sign, not proof.

When settlement deserves a look, and when it does not

Worth discussing if

  • A counselor has reviewed your budget and a repayment plan will not work
  • You can save toward lump-sum payments
  • You understand the credit damage and possible tax bill

Look elsewhere first if

  • You can still make your minimum payments
  • A consolidation loan or debt management plan would cover the cost
  • A collection lawsuit would be hard on you right now

Questions people ask

Do I have to pay someone for debt help?
No. You can ask your creditors directly, and nonprofit counselors often give free or low-cost advice. Ask about any fee first, and get it in writing.
How do I check a debt relief company?
Contact your state attorney general and local consumer protection agency, and ask the company for its fees in writing.
Can I quit a settlement program?
Under the FTC rule for debt relief sold by phone, you can leave a dedicated account at any time and get your money back, minus fees already earned. Your debts stay yours, and missed payments stay on your record.

Sources

  1. Debt relief services and the Telemarketing Sales Rule: a guide for business (FTC)
  2. How to get out of debt (FTC)
  3. What is a debt relief program and how do I know if I should use one? (CFPB)
  4. Advertisements for companies that consolidate credit card debt: are these legitimate? (CFPB)
  5. What is credit counseling? (CFPB)